Our 8 best butter cake recipes of all time
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(jpeg)/6585532_Neiman-Marcus-Cake_Peyton-Beckwith_4x3-b9bb165287ff4c4ab1c6a87b67add74c.jpg)
As with some of the most popular dishes in the Food World, the sticky butter cake was randomly invented. In the late 1930s or 1940s, a local baker in St. Louis in Missouri is said to have created the dessert by confusing the proportions of a traditional butter cake recipe. His error resulted in a delicious, thin, dense yellow cake with a sweet, sticky topping that is best cut into a bar.
Since then, Goeey Butter Cake (also known as chess cake) has been a popular staple in the middle west, especially in his hometown of St. Louis. Over the years, many versions of the decadent treat have occurred all over the country. Here are eight of our proven recipes, including favorites with a base for cake mixture and options with ingredients such as carrots and sweet potatoes.
Save myrecipes
Love one of these recipes? Tap “Save” to add you MyrecipesYour new, free recipe box for allrecipes.
Neiman Marcus Cake
Peyton Beckwith
Gooey Butter Cake tastes so luxurious that the dessert deserves the nickname Neiman Marcus Cake. It is unclear whether the Gooey Butter Cake is actually on the menu in the café of the shingled department store chain, but the name is still well received by home bakers. The evidence? This recipe for Neiman Marcus cake with 6-ingredient has almost 200 4.5-star reviews.
Gooey Butter Cake IV
Getty pictures
While most sticky butter cake recipes are now starting with a packages with cake mixture and cream cheese, the version of Allrecipes Community Shirleyo brings the classic back to the roots from the scratch. Your recipe has a simple lifting batter with rich topping with corn syrup and sugar.
Chocolate glue butter cake
Dotdash Meredith Studios
This brownie-like variant of sticky butter cake is made for chocolate lovers. “The cake like the recipe made as written,” says Sweetroe8375. “It brought it to a St. Patrick’s dinner and it was a great success. Thank you for another great recipe that I can add to my collection!”
Ooey GOEY COOTEN BUTTER cake
Allrecipes / Sonia Bozzo
“This ooey sticky carrot butter cake beats somewhere between a carrot cake, a chess bar and a cheesecake.” Says Allrecipes community member Tricia Manzanero. “It has crispy sugary edges, a sticky interior and a soft biscuit -like crust that makes the cake particularly tasty.”
Gooey Butter Cake II
Allrecipes community member Vicki Monte’s Gooey Butter Cake II is with important ingredients –Almond extract– Give the dessert a pleasant dose of nutty taste. “WOW!” Reviewer Gutsyyro2959. “Only Wow !!!! Fantastic !!! I ride out, but recipe said it and it was fantastic! I will make it safe again. I’m a baker from trade and that’s a big favorite.”
Apple butter sticky butter cake
Musselman’s apple butter
This perfect cake is enriched with a rich cup of apple butter, which gives the crumb a super -page texture and a lot of fruity taste. If you cannot find Musselman’s apple butter, you are welcome to exchange ideas in another brand!
Gooey sweet potato butter cake
“Simple dessert recipe that is perfect for the holidays,” says Dawn Stone, member of the Allrecipes community. “Every time I bring it somewhere, I am always asked about the recipe. If you are not a fan of sweet potatoes, bananas are a wonderful substitution.”
Sticky butter cake
Dotdash Meredith Food Studios
While many reviewers recommend reducing the amount of icing sugar in the recipe (they can use between two and four cups), it is an allrecipes community members who have the popular sticky butter cake recipes from allrecipes members. The all-caps check from OKWEBMOM is proof of this: “We have made this recipe since the early 80s. It is always a great success. For a different taste, you can add the” crust “mix” coconut and/or chopped pecans “.
